Republicans in Congress have been making behind-the-scenes efforts to go main home laws by way of the federal price range course of. They embrace potential cuts to Medicaid and lengthening the 2017 Trump tax cuts.
However despite the fact that it’s Congress’ job to go a price range and set tax coverage, most media retailers have been content material to border key parts of the laws as being pushed not by Congress however by the president.
So the information media say that the aim of the invoice is to “deliver Trump’s agenda” or to go the “Trump tax cuts.” Many have even adopted President Donald Trump’s trademark identify for the laws: his “big, beautiful bill.”
Together with Casey Burgat and SoRelle Wyckoff Gaynor, I’m co-author of a textbook titled “Congress Explained: Representation and Lawmaking in the First Branch.” In that ebook, it was necessary to us to spotlight Congress’ clear position because the preeminent lawmaking physique within the federal authorities.
However since Trump’s inauguration, Congress has ceded enormous swaths of its policymaking duty to the president. That makes the media’s deal with Trump unsurprising. And there’s no denying that Trump has had enormous impact throughout his first 100 days in workplace.
Throughout that point, Congress has been unwilling to say itself as an equal department of presidency. Past policymaking, Congress has been content material handy over a lot of its core constitutional powers to the manager department. As a Congress expert who loves the establishment and profoundly respects its constitutionally mandated position, this renunciation of duty has been tough to look at.
And but, Congress’ path to irrelevance as a physique of presidency didn’t start in January 2025.
It’s the results of a long time of abrasion that created a political tradition wherein Congress, the primary department of presidency listed within the Structure, is relegated to second-class standing.
Alex Wroblewski/AFP via Getty Images
The Structure places Congress first
The 18th-century framers of the Structure seen Congress as the muse of republican governance, intentionally placing it first in Article 1 to underscore its primacy. Congress was assigned the pivotal duties of lawmaking and budgeting as a result of controlling authorities funds was seen as important to limiting executive power and preventing abuses that the framers related to monarchy.
Alternatively, a weak legislature and an imperial executive had been exactly what lots of the founders feared. With legislative authority within the arms of Congress, energy would a minimum of be decentralized amongst all kinds of elected leaders from totally different components of the nation, every of whom would jealously guard their own local interests.
However Trump’s first 100 days turned the founders’ unique imaginative and prescient on its head, leaving the “first department” to play second fiddle.
Like most up-to-date presidents, Trump got here in along with his social gathering answerable for the presidency, the Home and the Senate. But regardless of the lawmaking energy that this governing trifecta can convey, the Republican majorities in Congress have largely been irrelevant to Trump’s agenda.
As an alternative, Congress has relied on Trump and the manager department to make modifications to federal coverage and in lots of instances to reshape the federal authorities fully.
Trump has signed more than 140 executive orders, a tempo sooner than any president since Franklin D. Roosevelt. The Republican Congress has proven little curiosity in pushing again on any of them. Trump has additionally aggressively reorganized, defunded or simply deleted complete companies, such because the U.S. Company for Worldwide Improvement and the Client Monetary Safety Bureau.
These actions have been carried out despite the fact that Congress has a transparent constitutional authority over the manager department’s price range. Once more, Congress has proven little to no real interest in reasserting its energy, even throughout recent budget talks.
Many causes, no simple options
Even so, Congress’ weakening didn’t start with Trump. There’s nobody wrongdoer however as an alternative a set of things which have offered the ineffectual Congress of at the moment.
One overriding issue is a course of that has unfolded over the previous 50 or extra years called political nationalization. American politics have turn into more and more centered on nationwide points, events and figures relatively than extra native considerations or people.
This shift has elevated the significance of the president because the symbolic and sensible chief of a nationwide social gathering agenda. Concurrently, it weakens the position of particular person members of Congress, who at the moment are extra prone to toe the social gathering line than signify native pursuits.
AP Photo/Rick Egan
Consequently, voters focus extra on presidential elections and fewer on congressional ones, granting the president higher affect and diminishing Congress’ unbiased authority.
The extra Congress polarizes amongst its members on a party-line foundation, the much less the general public is prone to belief the legitimacy of their opposition to a president. As an alternative, congressional pushback − typically as extreme as impeachment − can thus be written off not as principled or substantive however as partisan or politically motivated to a higher extent than ever earlier than.
Congress has additionally been been complicit in gifting away its personal energy. Particularly when coping with a polarized Congress, presidents more and more steer the ship in price range negotiations, which might result in extra native priorities – those Congress is meant to signify – being ignored.
However relatively than Congress staking out positions for itself, because it typically did by way of the flip of the twenty first century, political science analysis has proven that presidential positions on home coverage increasingly dictate – and polarize – Congress’ personal positions on coverage that hasn’t historically been divisive, comparable to funding assist for NASA. Congress’ positions on procedural points, comparable to elevating the debt ceiling or eliminating the filibuster, additionally more and more rely not on bedrock rules however on who occupies the White House.
Within the realm of overseas coverage, Congress has all but abandoned its constitutional energy to declare struggle, settling as an alternative for “authorizations” of navy power that the president desires to say. These give the commander in chief extensive latitude over struggle powers, and each Democratic and Republican presidents have been joyful to retain that energy. They’ve used these congressional approvals to engage in extended conflicts such as the Gulf War within the early Nineteen Nineties and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan a decade later.
What’s misplaced with a weak Congress
People lose rather a lot when Congress arms over such drastic energy to the manager department.
When particular person members of Congress from throughout the nation take a again seat, their districts’ distinctly native issues are much less prone to be addressed with the facility and sources that Congress can convey to a problem. Necessary native views on nationwide points fail to be represented in Congress.
Even members of the identical political social gathering signify districts with vastly totally different economies, demographics and geography. Members are supposed to maintain this in thoughts when legislating on these points, however presidential management over the method makes that tough and even inconceivable.
Perhaps extra importantly, a weak Congress paired with what historian Arthur Schlesinger known as the “Imperial Presidency” is a recipe for an unaccountable president, working wild with out the constitutionally offered oversight and checks on energy that the founders offered to the folks by way of their illustration by the primary department of presidency.
