After years of mounting scrutiny over TikTok’s information practices, in 2024 the Chinese language video platform was threatened with a pressured sale within the US or a nationwide ban. With the deadline looming on June 19, US–China tech rivalry has entered a brand new and extra aggressive part. TikTok vowed to combat pressured divestment, claiming it might “trample” free speech.
However what began as an argument over information privateness now has world implications. This battle is about extra than simply an app. It represents a shift within the steadiness of digital energy — one that would redefine how nations view nationwide safety, financial sovereignty and the web itself.
In gentle of my research on AI bias, algorithmic equity, and the societal influence of digital platforms and my expertise advising authorities on AI regulation and digital ethics, I see TikTok because the flashpoint of a broader, extra harmful pattern. Digital areas have gotten battlefronts for geopolitical affect.
TikTok has developed from a social media app to – within the eyes of some policymakers – a digital weapon. Its huge world following has made it a cultural juggernaut. However this viral success has additionally made it a primary goal within the escalating US-China tech warfare.
Get your information from precise consultants, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our daily newsletter to obtain all The Dialog UK’s newest protection of reports and analysis, from politics and enterprise to the humanities and sciences.
US politicians fear that its owner, ByteDance, may very well be pressured by the Chinese language authorities handy over American consumer information, or manipulate TikTok’s algorithm to serve Beijing’s political agenda.
The issues are severe, even when not confirmed. Platforms have been used to sway political sentiment earlier than — as with Fb within the Cambridge Analytica scandal. However TikTok is completely different. Its algorithm isn’t like these of different social platforms that depend on a consumer’s social graph (what you observe, who you recognize) to attach folks, organisations and locations.
As an alternative, TikTok makes use of a real-time advice system based mostly on micro-interactions: how lengthy you watch a video, whether or not you pause or replay it and even your swipe patterns. The result’s an ultra-addictive content material stream. This provides TikTok an nearly unprecedented energy to form opinions, whether or not deliberately or not.
TikTok within the US: three attainable eventualities
There are three potential outcomes for TikTok. The primary is a pressured sale to a US-based entity, which may fulfill lawmakers however doubtless provoke extreme retaliation from China.
The second is a ban, which can be extra symbolic than efficient, however would ship a powerful message. The third, and maybe most definitely, is an extended, drawn-out authorized battle that ends in a stalemate. Trump appears set to extend the June 19 deadline, in any case.
However there’s a deeper subject right here. The world is changing into more and more divided alongside digital strains. The US and China are constructing rival digital ecosystems, every suspicious of the opposite’s platforms.
Like previous restrictions on Huawei and Nvidia chip exports, this case alerts how nationwide safety and financial coverage are merging within the digital age. This threatens to splinter the web, with nations selecting sides for his or her suppliers based mostly on political and financial allegiances relatively than technical advantage.
For China, TikTok is a logo of nationwide pleasure. It’s one of many few Chinese language apps to realize world success and develop into a family identify in western markets. Forcing ByteDance to promote TikTok, or banning it, may very well be seen as an affront to China’s ambitions on the worldwide digital stage. It’s now not nearly a platform — it’s about management over the way forward for know-how.
TikTok’s defenders argue that banning the app would undermine free speech, stifle creativity and unfairly goal a foreign-owned platform. These issues are legitimate, however the broader panorama of digital platforms is way from simple.
Different platforms have faced criticism over allegations of spreading misinformation, amplifying bias and contributing to social harm. Nonetheless, the important thing distinction with TikTok lies in its algorithm and its capability to sway opinions on a world scale.
TikTok’s “for you” feed tracks micro-interactions, serving up personalised content material with an addictive depth. Because of this, customers can discover themselves pulled deeper into curated content material streams with out realising the extent to which their preferences are being formed.
Whereas its opponents may have the ability to unfold misinformation and stoke division in additional conventional methods, TikTok may doubtlessly achieve this by the finely tuned manipulation of the consumer’s consideration. It is a potent instrument on this planet of digital politics.
It additionally raises crucial questions on how the US approaches regulation. Is TikTok a real nationwide safety menace or just a logo of the rising strategic competitors between two superpowers?
EPA-EFE/JIM LO SCALZO / POOL
Quite than counting on bans and commerce wars, what is required is powerful, cross-border frameworks that prioritise transparency, information safety, algorithmic accountability and the mitigation of on-line harms.
Considerations about harassment, disinformation, addictive design and algorithms that amplify poisonous content material are usually not distinctive to TikTok. US laws such because the Kids Online Safety Act and the proposed Platform Accountability and Transparency Act sign rising concern. However these efforts stay piecemeal.
The EU’s Digital Services Act is a welcome mannequin for accountability. However world coordination is now important. With out it, there’s the danger of additional fragmentation of the web (what has been known as the “splinternet” — the place entry is decided by geopolitics relatively than common ideas).
The digital world has lengthy been dominated by a handful of highly effective firms. Now it’s more and more formed by state rivalries. The battle over TikTok is a harbinger of deeper tensions round how information, affect and belief are distributed on-line.
The true query now is just not whether or not TikTok survives, however whether or not nations can craft a digital future that prioritises democratic values, cross-border collaboration and the general public good. This isn’t nearly nationwide safety or free speech. It’s a defining second within the battle for the way forward for the web.
